
It was Miss AMP who introduced me to Frances Morgan.
Almost immediately, I got into an argument about her. I wanted to send her to interview Sonic Youth for Careless Talk Costs Lives and the press agent was concerned that I was commissioning an untested music critic (Frances was, and remains, a talented musician) to talk to her flagship band. I responded that I'm just as able to spot intelligence, passion - and something else, being driven - as anyone, and so Frances went down to speak to her favourite band as her first interview as a critic.
Afterwards the PR graciously let me know that she (and the band) thought the interview went great.
For a long time after, I kind of wished I hadn't introduced Frances into the fold - her writing (like that of Neil Kulkarni, Stevie Chick and Miss AMP, for quite different reasons) always made me feel inadequate, in its ability to describe music so imaginatively.
Right from the start, Frances has been crucial, the main part of Plan B Magazine. I might have helped conceptualise and realise the magazine, alongside Chris Houghton and Andrew Clare (and lesser-sung names such as the wonderful Richard Stacey) but it was Frances, right from the outset, who was the driving force behind the title. My role at Plan B has always been advisory, to a lesser or greater degree. It was her vision and dedication and hard work and enthusiasm that have filled its pages, attracted the contributors, kept the title going way beyond what I (and Chris, I suspect) believed to be its natural lifespan. She commissioned the stories, proof-read the stories, oversaw the content and section editors. Even cleaned the bloody offices!
In the past year she moved into the role of publisher to allow Louis Pattison to take a very able crack at being editor - but simply, she did that to try and give Plan B one last chance to survive following my departure to Australia. Tons of other people contributed - very high on my list would be kicking_k, whose examplary taste (i.e. it often agrees with mine) and enthusiasm and ability to discover great music I've had cause to comment on before; but also the ever-reliable and visionary design skills of Andrew Clare, the initial and crucial burst of energy and business acumen supplied by Chris Houghton, and folk like Cat and Sarah and Lauren and Thee Stevie Chick, and Nick Taylor, our ads manager who singlehandedly gave the title at least another year of life, David McNamee, who did so much to help define the character of the magazine at the start, and all the sections editors, and Jesus the contributors, awesome folk who I'm so pleased to have worked alongside, the photographers, interns, illustrators, ad reps, supportive PRs, record industry people...you know this list could go on for a very long time...but without Frances there, every fucking hour of the day, Plan B simply wouldn't have made it to issue 15, let alone 45.
I'm getting choked up. Obviously, I've been aware of the imminent demise of Plan B for some time - but it's one thing just sharing that knowledge among a few likeminded souls, and another having it made public.
I mean, Jesus, we didn't do so bad, did we? Built ourselves into a national magazine from scratch with no outside funding, and lasted four-and-a-half years. Folk are already talking about this as one more nail into the coffin of the print media, but actually I think the advent of web 2.0 had little to do with Plan B's demise. Sure, it's related to the way the music industry is mutating. Sure, it's related to the global recession, localised - but Plan B was too much a niche title for web 2.0 to have that much of an effect.
Don't think of this as an ending. Think of this as a beginning. We're not going to go away. The website and forum are still up and running - and with no intent to close either. And we're still going to be out there, thriving, adapting, inspiring, challenging. There's no fucking way we're going to go away now.
Plan B Magazine R.I.P.
Pulling Shapes
Ned Raggett
Drowned In Sound
Plan B

You really didn't do so bad. Take several bows.
ReplyDeleteAnd in 20 years' time, there'll be a nostalgic TV show and you can all talk wonderfully contradictory nonsense about like they do about Oz and Modern Review and NMEWhenItWasn'tShit.
I'm still all waaah this morning, but thank you - that feels a bit better.
ReplyDeleteThrive online
ReplyDeleteIf that was going to happen Tim, I'd already be doing it! I've been around a fair while y'know...
ReplyDeleteVale. I enjoyed it thoroughly when I was in the UK. Best wishes to all involved.
ReplyDeleteaww...we were a force for good for half a decade. not many can say that. thx for the opportunity, everett, it'll always be appreciated. yr presence in the Plan B office has been missed -
ReplyDeletei think it's time you took on the oz scene - a mag filtering the world for that audience, and hopefully seeding a new wave of bands wd be a hell of a challenge - and an achievement.
also: props to David McNamee, who did a lot to make Plan B into what it was.
[...] Everett’s piece on its close, which gives lots of rightful props to Frances May Morgan. Here’s Ned Raggett putting Plan B in context, which does a good job of hailing it without [...]
ReplyDelete[...] Gillen’… on RIP Plan Beveretttrue on RIP Plan BArthit on RIP Plan BDay 68 Plan B Magazi… on RIP [...]
ReplyDeleteThis is indeed a sad day. I know I work for another magazine, but I don't enjoy the prospect of have one less decent music/arts mag out there. I've always been a fan of Plan B (even applied for a job there once!), and will miss it.
ReplyDeleteThanks all. Please go over to the Plan B forum as well and let them know how you feel. Re: kicking_k's comment - absolutely. David was there right at the start with a suitcase full of great ideas (and, as ever, great writing). I've amended the post to acknowledge this.
ReplyDeleteThanks ET - very kind of you. To clarify, as it happens, my first interview for you was actually with Jon Spencer Blues Explosion about a month before that. First off I asked them if people still came to their gigs these days, and if so, who exactly? Then we had a disagreement about whether werewolves were American or European in origin. It was really fun to write up afterwards, but maybe it's best that you skipped straight to the Sonic Youth piece. :-)
ReplyDeleteI'd just like to second Kick's mention of David McNamee. He defined the character of Plan B in its early days as much as I did.
Thanks everyone else for your nice comments and props.
FMx
Damn. You're quite right. Sigh. There goes a great story.
ReplyDelete2004-2009 Plan B R.I.P.
ReplyDeleteBought the first issue at Virgin Megastore in Chicago and never miss any issue. This is a sad day in music.
Arthit (perhaps the only subscribers in Bangkok).
Still use the story. Remember what John Ford said: when in doubt, print the legend.
ReplyDeleteYeah...I suppose I just feel odd about it because by that point I'd written professionally for some other places, and was a working sub-editor also. But yeah, what really matters is this: I probably wouldn't have got much further without the awesome support of ET and the community of like-minded sorts on CTCL. It was certainly the first time I was given the chance to find and use my own voice, and I will always be eternally grateful for that. So in that sense, it's the perfect story. It also illustrates something very important about CTCL and Plan B: that new writers were encouraged. It didn't matter 'who' you were: if we felt instinctively that someone was the right person for job, we got them to do it.
ReplyDeleteAnyways - I can't wait to see what everyone does next.
Sorry, that's not meant to sound in the least bit churlish or ungrateful for the incredibly generous stuff said about me in the post - I do appreciate that. I think I'm just crap at accepting praise!
ReplyDeletei felt so sad to hear of this today. for me, plan b has always had the kind of flawed brilliance i associate with fanzines - passion, mistakes, personality, taking chances; sometimes shining a light, and sometimes being a bit what the fuck. but at its best it gave importance to a lot of music that is either unregarded or on the margin of the margins. i always really looked forward to an issue.
ReplyDeleteand i suppose i will always associate it with you, et, although you had a great team there who were able to move things forward even when you weren't around. i think it was a much greater achievement than getting in on nirvana early on, but then i will always prefer the legend fanzine to creation records. ego's ok sometimes but there was great community in this. i'm really proud to have been a contributor to the magazine and i wish geographic had tons of money for advertising so that we could have supported it more. anyway, well done. for a moment (five years), it was something great.
[...] Day 68 Plan B Magazine R.I.P. It was Miss AMP who introduced me to Frances Morgan. [...] [...]
ReplyDelete[...] hot on the heels of that news comes word that renegade UK rag Plan B has decided to pull the plug on their operation. This saddens me deeply, as Plan B, and it’s predecessor Careless Talk Costs Lives were among [...]
ReplyDeleteIt's a sad day when any music publication meets it's untimely demise and after coming to terms with the early death of Careless Talk Costs Lives and Comes With A Smile among others, I thought Plan B would continue to fill that left of centre hole, now we're going to be left with pages of so-called "buzz acts" via the mainstream music press and have to rely on word of mouth to discover the more interesting acts out there.
ReplyDeleteIt's a grim day for music in general but thanks to everyone at Plan B for supply us, the readers with hours of enjoyment whilst it lasted.
[...] Ironic that this was the first post I made after hearing the news of Plan B’s demise – as Speech Debelle was the cover star on the final issue of Plan B. I had no idea at [...]
ReplyDelete[...] a link on Facebook to a much-loved Plan B cover star (she was, right?) covering Journey on her MySpace page. Holy simmering shit. I have no [...]
ReplyDelete